The insurer was added as a defendant to an action after the limitation period running from the date of the motor vehicle accident had expired due to discoverability issues but the insurer was at liberty to plead a limitation defence

Insurance law – Automobile insurance – Unidentified motorist – Limitation of actions – Running of limitation period – Discoverability – Practice – Parties to action – Adding a party Bhatt v. John Doe, [2018] O.J. No. 759, 2018 ONSC 950, Ontario Superior Court of Justice, February 9, 2018, Master B. McAfee The plaintiffs were passengers ...

Strata building sprinkler system held to be a plumbing delivery and distribution system, and therefore defects in material and labour for the sprinkler system enjoyed a two year warranty

09. March 2018 0
The strata building sprinkler system was held to be a plumbing delivery and distribution system, and therefore defects in material and labour for the sprinkler system enjoyed a two year warranty. Insurance law – Homeowner warranty insurance – Coverage – Expired policy – Property – Strata Corporations Strata Plan 4249 v. Travelers Insurance Co. of Canada, ...

Insured’s fleet policy excludes underinsured motorist coverage, but coverage found in personal vehicles’ policy

09. March 2018 0
A notation of “PP/LC” which qualified a grant of underinsured motorist coverage excluded coverage for the insured as he was neither a private passenger nor driving a light commercial vehicle, but coverage was found in another policy with a similar underinsured motorist coverage clause that did not contain the qualifying notation. Insurance law – Automobile ...

Insured awarded mental distress and punitive damages where insurer found to have failed to act in good faith in the handling of the insured’s disability claim

09. March 2018 0
The insurer was found to have failed to act in good faith in the handling of the insured’s disability claim and the insured was awarded mental distress and punitive damages. Insurance law – Disability insurance – Punitive damages – Mental distress – Medical examination – Good faith Godwin v. Desjardins Financial Security Investments Inc., [2018] ...

Breach of contract claim for failing to add party as an additional insured in contractor’s liability policy found to be time-barred

09. March 2018 0
A breach of contract claim for failing to add a party as an additional insured in a contractor’s liability policy was time-barred by virtue of the operation of Ontario’s Limitation Act. Insurance law – Liability insurance – Additional named insured – Duty to defend – Contracts – Privity of contract – Limitation of actions Brookstreet ...

Insurer obligated to contribute to defence costs and settlement in personal injury lawsuit where insured’s homeowner’s policy found not to operate as an excess liability policy

09. March 2018 0
An insured’s homeowner’s policy was held not to operate as an excess liability policy, obligating the insurer to contribute to defence costs and settlement respecting a lawsuit arising out of a fall that occurred after hours at the insured’s business premises. Insurance law – Homeowner’s insurance – Bodily injury – Corporate capacity – Excess liability ...

Insurers had duty to defend insureds against claim for damages arising from alleged migration of contamination notwithstanding environmental and pollution liability exclusions in policies

13. February 2018 0
Insurance law – Commercial general liability insurance – Pollution exclusions – Duty to defend – Costs – Special costs West Van Holdings Ltd. v. Economical Mutual Insurance Co., [2017] B.C.J. No. 2670, 2017 BCSC 2397, British Columbia Supreme Court, December 29, 2017, DeWitt-Van Oosten J. The insureds were sued for damages allegedly due to the migration ...

Mortgagor’s claim to proceeds of fire loss paid out under standard mortgage clause took priority over CRA’s claim due to mortgagee’s tax liability

13. February 2018 0
Insurance law – Mortgages – Standard mortgage clause – Priority coverage Travelers Canada v. Elite Builders Inc., [2017] N.J. No. 432, 2017 NLTD(G) 214, Newfoundland and Labrador Supreme Court – Trial Division – General Division, December 22, 2017, G.L. Murphy J. A dispute arose between the Canada Revenue Agency (“CRA”) and a mortgage lender over ...

Insured’s soft-tissue injuries did not amount to “permanent serious impairment of an important physical, mental, or psychological function” and therefore award of general damages by jury disallowed

13. February 2018 0
Insurance law – Automobile insurance – Unidentified motorist – Statutory obligations – Damages – Permanent impairment, definition – Damages – Jury trials Nadarajah v. Aviva Canada Inc., [2017] O.J. No. 6571, 2017 ONSC 7522, Ontario Superior Court of Justice, December 18, 2017, P.J. Monahan J. The insured brought a claim for damages arising out of a motor ...

Appeal from partial summary judgment in which court made a declaration relating to the interpretation of a section of a banker’s comprehensive liability policy allowed

13. February 2018 0
Insurance law – Liability insurance – Directors and officers liability insurance – Interpretation of policy – Statutory provisions – Practice – Appeals – Summary judgments TD Bank N.A. v. Lloyd’s Underwriters, [2017] O.J. No. 6722, 2017 ONCA 1011, Ontario Court of Appeal, December 21, 2017, J.M. Simmons, D.M. Brown and J.M. Fairburn JJ.A. The insurer appealed ...